Erie County, New York Medicare Advantage
In October 2026, CMS counted 156,444 Medicare Advantage enrollees in Erie County, New York across 12 parent carriers, led by Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. with 22.7%. That is +1.7% versus October 2025, and 71.7% of Medicare beneficiaries here are in Medicare Advantage.
Advantage enrollees
156,444
October 2026
All Medicare beneficiaries
219,321
CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024
Dual-eligible
45,994
CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024
Part D enrollees
179,266
CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024
Largest Medicare Advantage plans in Erie County, New York
Plans are individual-market Medicare Advantage plans (employer group plans excluded), ranked by CMS counted enrollment. Star ratings are CMS contract-level Overall ratings: the current rating is in effect this year; the next rating was released in October for the coming plan year.
| # | Plan | Carrier | Type | Enrollees | 2026 stars | 2027 stars |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Univera SeniorChoice Basic (HMO) H3351-017 | Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 17,992 | 4 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 2 | Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO) H5521-381 | CVS Health Corporation | Local PPO | 11,715 | 4.5 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 3 | UHC Dual Complete NY-S002 (HMO-POS D-SNP) H3387-014 · Special Needs Plan | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 10,971 | 4 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 4 | Independent Health's Encompass 65 RED 044 (HMO) H3362-044 | Independent Health Association, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 10,093 | 5 ★ | 4.5 ★ |
| 5 | Univera SeniorChoice Extra (HMO) H3351-020 | Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 9,240 | 4 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 6 | AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC NY-0007 (HMO-POS) H3379-040 | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 9,076 | 3.5 ★ | 3.5 ★ |
| 7 | Community Blue Medicare HMO Signature (HMO) H3384-069 | Highmark Health | HMO/HMOPOS | 6,427 | 4 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 8 | Independent Health's Encompass 65 RED 042 (HMO) H3362-042 | Independent Health Association, Inc. | HMO/HMOPOS | 4,799 | 5 ★ | 4.5 ★ |
| 9 | Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO) H5521-215 | CVS Health Corporation | Local PPO | 4,376 | 4.5 ★ | 4 ★ |
| 10 | Senior Blue 651 (HMO) H3384-019 | Highmark Health | HMO/HMOPOS | 3,118 | 4 ★ | 4 ★ |
Carrier growth and decline in Erie County, New York
Change in counted enrollment since October 2025.
Biggest gains
- Lifetime Healthcare, Inc.+21,076 (+146.7%)
- CVS Health Corporation+14,809 (+222.7%)
- UnitedHealth Group, Inc.+2,459 (+8.3%)
- Humana Inc.+1,275 (+43.7%)
- Visiting Nurse Service of New York+463 (+890.4%)
Biggest declines
- Highmark Health-18,499 (-47.8%)
- Independent Health Association, Inc.-18,044 (-33.8%)
- Centene Corporation-934 (-12.1%)
- MVP Health Care, Inc.-56 (-56.6%)
- Elevance Health, Inc.-36 (-10.2%)
Carriers in Erie County, New York
CMS Monthly Enrollment by Contract/Plan/State/County (CPSC) · October 2026
| # | Parent organisation | Enrollees | Share | vs October 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. | 35,444 | 22.7% | +146.7% |
| 2 | Independent Health Association, Inc. | 35,304 | 22.6% | -33.8% |
| 3 | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. | 32,116 | 20.5% | +8.3% |
| 4 | CVS Health Corporation | 21,460 | 13.7% | +222.7% |
| 5 | Highmark Health | 20,215 | 12.9% | -47.8% |
| 6 | Centene Corporation | 6,771 | 4.3% | -12.1% |
| 7 | Humana Inc. | 4,194 | 2.7% | +43.7% |
| 8 | Visiting Nurse Service of New York | 515 | 0.3% | +890.4% |
| 9 | Elevance Health, Inc. | 318 | 0.2% | -10.2% |
| 10 | VISITING NURSE ASSOCIATION OF CENTRAL NEW YORK | 53 | 0.0% | +55.9% |
| 11 | MVP Health Care, Inc. | 43 | 0.0% | -56.6% |
| 12 | Health Care Service Corporation | 11 | 0.0% | — |
What is missing
CMS suppresses any plan-county cell with fewer than 11 enrollees. Those enrollees are missing from these counts, so every figure is a floor, not an exact total.
What is counted
Counts cover Medicare Advantage contracts only (Local CCP, Regional CCP, PFFS and MSA). Standalone Part D drug plans, cost plans, HCPP and PACE contracts are excluded.
Source: CMS Monthly Enrollment by Contract/Plan/State/County (CPSC).
