All Pennsylvania counties
Free tool · public CMS data

Butler County, Pennsylvania Medicare Advantage

In October 2026, CMS counted 35,495 Medicare Advantage enrollees in Butler County, Pennsylvania across 12 parent carriers, led by Highmark Health with 32.8%. That is +2.4% versus October 2025, and 69.6% of Medicare beneficiaries here are in Medicare Advantage.

Advantage enrollees

35,495

October 2026

All Medicare beneficiaries

51,664

CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024

Dual-eligible

5,073

CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024

Part D enrollees

41,676

CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment, 2024

Largest Medicare Advantage plans in Butler County, Pennsylvania

Plans are individual-market Medicare Advantage plans (employer group plans excluded), ranked by CMS counted enrollment. Star ratings are CMS contract-level Overall ratings: the current rating is in effect this year; the next rating was released in October for the coming plan year.

#PlanCarrierTypeEnrollees2026 stars2027 stars
1Complete Blue PPO Distinct (PPO)
H3916-035
Highmark HealthLocal PPO3,8724.5 ★4.5 ★
2Aetna Medicare Advantra Premier (HMO-POS)
H3959-002
CVS Health CorporationHMO/HMOPOS2,5334 ★3.5 ★
3Aetna Medicare Advantra Signature Plus (HMO-POS)
H3959-011
CVS Health CorporationHMO/HMOPOS2,3124 ★3.5 ★
4UPMC for Life HMO Rx Choice (HMO)
H3907-057
UPMC Health SystemHMO/HMOPOS1,9014.5 ★4.5 ★
5Community Blue Medicare HMO Signature (HMO)
H3957-047
Highmark HealthHMO/HMOPOS1,4304.5 ★4.5 ★
6UPMC for Life PPO Rx Choice (PPO)
H5533-015
UPMC Health SystemLocal PPO1,4194.5 ★4.5 ★
7UPMC for Life HMO Rx (HMO)
H3907-058
UPMC Health SystemHMO/HMOPOS1,3564.5 ★4.5 ★
8UPMC for Life HMO Premier Rx (HMO)
H3907-059
UPMC Health SystemHMO/HMOPOS1,2704.5 ★4.5 ★
9Aetna Medicare Value Plus (PPO)
H5522-005
CVS Health CorporationLocal PPO1,2534.5 ★4.5 ★
10UPMC for Life Complete Care (HMO D-SNP)
H4279-001 · Special Needs Plan
UPMC Health SystemHMO/HMOPOS1,0134 ★3.5 ★

Carrier growth and decline in Butler County, Pennsylvania

Change in counted enrollment since October 2025. New since then: Devoted Health, Inc..

Biggest gains

  • Highmark Health+818 (+7.6%)
  • Humana Inc.+161 (+19.5%)
  • Elevance Health, Inc.+62 (+7.1%)
  • Health Care Service Corporation+49 (+27.2%)
  • UPMC Health System+12 (+0.1%)

Biggest declines

  • UnitedHealth Group, Inc.-189 (-6.1%)
  • CVS Health Corporation-120 (-1.2%)
  • Independence Health Group, Inc.-24 (-35.3%)
  • Centene Corporation-16 (-12.8%)

Carriers in Butler County, Pennsylvania

CMS Monthly Enrollment by Contract/Plan/State/County (CPSC) · October 2026

#Parent organisationEnrolleesSharevs October 2025
1Highmark Health11,62632.8%+7.6%
2CVS Health Corporation9,54226.9%-1.2%
3UPMC Health System8,95725.2%+0.1%
4UnitedHealth Group, Inc.2,9268.2%-6.1%
5Humana Inc.9852.8%+19.5%
6Elevance Health, Inc.9372.6%+7.1%
7Health Care Service Corporation2290.6%+27.2%
8Centene Corporation1090.3%-12.8%
9Rifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC670.2%+19.6%
10Devoted Health, Inc.600.2%New
11Independence Health Group, Inc.440.1%-35.3%
12Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.130.0%+18.2%

What is missing

CMS suppresses any plan-county cell with fewer than 11 enrollees. Those enrollees are missing from these counts, so every figure is a floor, not an exact total.

What is counted

Counts cover Medicare Advantage contracts only (Local CCP, Regional CCP, PFFS and MSA). Standalone Part D drug plans, cost plans, HCPP and PACE contracts are excluded.

Source: CMS Monthly Enrollment by Contract/Plan/State/County (CPSC).

Plan your Butler County territory

RepVector ranks markets and builds target lists from this plus sixty other public sources.

Build the Butler County, Pennsylvania list

3 free runs — no card required.