New York: Outpatient hospital billing outliers
In 2024, CMS reported 128 OPPS hospitals, 293,356 comprehensive APC services and approximately $1,336,779,183 in Medicare payments in this state. 0 hospitals have at least one payment-per-service flag.
Compared with 2023
Loading earlier CMS data…
Payment per service relative to same-APC peers
Payment comparison rule
Flagged when average Medicare payment per service is above 2× the median for the same comprehensive APC in this state, with at least 20 hospitals. A higher payment can reflect geographic adjustments, case complexity or legitimate extra payments—not fraud.
CMS “outlier services” means a specific OPPS extra-payment category; it is not this page’s peer-comparison flag.
Hospital billing by comprehensive APC
2,932 matching hospital/APC rows. Summary totals cover all published rows for the state.
| Hospital / CCN | APC | Services | Medicare paid | Payment / service | Peer median | Why flagged |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills Harris · CCN 330386 | 5313 Level 3 Lower GI Procedures | 16 | $43,232 | $2,702 | $2,475 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital New York · CCN 330101 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 147 | $2,869,553 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · CCN 330024 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 27 | $527,061 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Nyack Hospital Nyack · CCN 330104 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 19 | $370,895 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| New York Community Hospital Of Brooklyn, Inc. Brooklyn · CCN 330019 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 15 | $292,812 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Staten Island University Hospital Staten Island · CCN 330160 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 13 | $253,770 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Hudson Valley Hospital Center Cortlandt Manor · CCN 330267 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 11 | $214,728 | $19,521 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital Cooperstown · CCN 330136 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 19 | $370,045 | $19,476 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca Ithaca · CCN 330307 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 16 | $311,617 | $19,476 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Olean General Hospital Olean · CCN 330103 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 12 | $233,713 | $19,476 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| White Plains Hospital Center White Plains · CCN 330304 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 50 | $972,525 | $19,450 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Hudson Valley Hospital Center Cortlandt Manor · CCN 330267 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 96 | $1,278,343 | $13,316 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Memorial Hospital For Cancer And Allied Diseases New York · CCN 330154 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 48 | $639,171 | $13,316 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Montefiore New Rochelle Hospital New Rochelle · CCN 330184 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 56 | $745,700 | $13,316 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Maimonides Medical Center Brooklyn · CCN 330194 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 56 | $745,700 | $13,316 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| St Joseph's Medical Center Yonkers · CCN 330006 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 21 | $279,637 | $13,316 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern Suffern · CCN 330158 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 75 | $998,530 | $13,314 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| New York Community Hospital Of Brooklyn, Inc. Brooklyn · CCN 330019 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 21 | $104,628 | $4,982 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Maimonides Medical Center Brooklyn · CCN 330194 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 21 | $104,628 | $4,982 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Hudson Valley Hospital Center Cortlandt Manor · CCN 330267 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 16 | $79,716 | $4,982 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital New York · CCN 330101 | 5164 Level 4 ENT Procedures | 43 | $125,517 | $2,919 | $2,720 23 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · CCN 330024 | 5164 Level 4 ENT Procedures | 27 | $78,813 | $2,919 | $2,720 23 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Memorial Hospital For Cancer And Allied Diseases New York · CCN 330154 | 5164 Level 4 ENT Procedures | 22 | $64,218 | $2,919 | $2,720 23 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Suny Health Science Center At Brooklyn University Brooklyn · CCN 330350 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 33 | $164,405 | $4,982 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| St John's Riverside Hospital Yonkers · CCN 330208 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 19 | $252,770 | $13,304 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Hudson Valley Hospital Center Cortlandt Manor · CCN 330267 | 5313 Level 3 Lower GI Procedures | 24 | $63,641 | $2,652 | $2,475 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Aurelia Osborn Fox Memorial Hospital Oneonta · CCN 330085 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 22 | $292,259 | $13,285 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital Cooperstown · CCN 330136 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 39 | $518,096 | $13,285 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Auburn Community Hospital Auburn · CCN 330235 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 27 | $358,682 | $13,285 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Jones Memorial Hospital Wellsville · CCN 330096 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 14 | $185,983 | $13,285 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Brooks-Tlc Hospital System, Inc Dunkirk · CCN 330229 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 12 | $159,414 | $13,285 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Canton-Potsdam Hospital Potsdam · CCN 330197 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 33 | $438,386 | $13,284 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca Ithaca · CCN 330307 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 173 | $2,297,919 | $13,283 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| The University Of Vermont Health Network - Champl Plattsburgh · CCN 330250 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 19 | $94,463 | $4,972 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Claxton-Hepburn Medical Center Ogdensburg · CCN 330211 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 22 | $292,122 | $13,278 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · CCN 330024 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 37 | $53,724 | $1,452 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Richmond University Medical Center Staten Island · CCN 330028 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 25 | $36,300 | $1,452 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern Suffern · CCN 330158 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 15 | $21,780 | $1,452 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Suny Health Science Center At Brooklyn University Brooklyn · CCN 330350 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 11 | $15,972 | $1,452 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital New York · CCN 330101 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 596 | $7,909,510 | $13,271 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · CCN 330024 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 230 | $3,049,380 | $13,258 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Nyack Hospital Nyack · CCN 330104 | 5115 Level 5 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 121 | $1,603,222 | $13,250 | $12,400 91 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Samaritan Medical Center Watertown · CCN 330157 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 18 | $26,081 | $1,449 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Auburn Community Hospital Auburn · CCN 330235 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 14 | $20,285 | $1,449 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| St Francis Hospital, Roslyn Roslyn · CCN 330182 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 67 | $1,294,041 | $19,314 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai South Nassau Oceanside · CCN 330198 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 18 | $347,653 | $19,314 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Brookdale Hospital Medical Center Brooklyn · CCN 330233 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 19 | $27,521 | $1,448 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| St Anthony Community Hospital Warwick · CCN 330205 | 5116 Level 6 Musculoskeletal Procedures | 60 | $1,157,276 | $19,288 | $18,079 51 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Maimonides Medical Center Brooklyn · CCN 330194 | 5182 Level 2 Vascular Procedures | 29 | $41,920 | $1,446 | $1,356 70 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
| Mount Sinai Hospital New York · CCN 330024 | 5184 Level 4 Vascular Procedures | 148 | $732,213 | $4,947 | $4,642 55 same-APC hospitals | No rule hit |
Coverage and limitations
Source: CMS Medicare Outpatient Hospitals by Provider and Service. Original Medicare Part B at OPPS hospitals only; no Medicare Advantage, Medicaid or commercial claims. Maryland and territories are outside this file. Low-volume rows are suppressed by CMS.
Payments and charges are derived from the published average per service multiplied by C-APC service count; charges are not payments. C-APCs bundle multiple services, and this is not a line-level CPT/HCPCS claims file. Totals only cover the published C-APCs, not all hospital revenue.
An outlier is a comparison to review, not proof of fraud, improper billing or an exclusion.
