TMS Medicare spend in Massachusetts
Initial treatment and motor-threshold determination, subsequent treatments, and motor-threshold re-determination—with published Medicare services, patient bounds, payments and same-code peer evidence.
CMS cohort fetched 2026-11-07T23:23:37.341Z · All three code reads complete · 0 NPI matches in saved OIG LEIE
Estimated Medicare paid
$1.6M
No comparable prior value
Published services
9,185
No comparable prior value
Rendering providers
24
2 with peer flags
Summed provider patient bounds
488–669
Not unique patients across providers
Paid per service
$173
Mix-dependent; not used as a cross-code flag
Top 10 provider payment share
71.6%
Published fee-for-service market only
Year-over-year payments
Provider-type payment mix
Services per patient — lower-bound distribution
No annual clinical maximum is inferred; the last bin includes all values of 95 or higher.
Providers in Massachusetts
24 providers · code filter selects providers billing that code; totals remain the complete TMS code mix.
Directory matches use the current CMS Doctors and Clinicians PECOS-derived file, not historical billing addresses. Multiple practice locations are retained; enrollment does not prove employment, active licensure or wrongdoing.
| Provider / location | Codes | Patients (bounds) | Services | Services / patient | Medicare paid | Screening | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ronald Winfield North Chelmsford, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 13–25 | 773 | 30.9–59.5 | $135,251 | 100 · High | |
| Mahdi Razafsha Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 37–37 | 430 | 11.6–11.6 | $74,305 | 23 · Low | |
| Mathews Thomas Brockton, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 13–24 | 420 | 17.5–32.3 | $74,324 | 13 · Low | |
| Sabrina Dar Waltham, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 20–39 | 608 | 15.6–30.4 | $107,981 | 8 · Low | |
| Jonathan Schwartz New Bedford, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868, 90869 | 77–161 | 2,269 | 14.1–29.5 | $401,396 | 5 · Low | |
| John Zebrun Northampton, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 12–12 | 341 | 28.4–28.4 | $58,905 | 5 · Low | |
| Madhavi Kamireddi Acton, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 18–34 | 519 | 15.3–28.8 | $91,675 | 4 · Low | |
| William Bache Brockton, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 11–11 | 292 | 26.5–26.5 | $50,500 | 2 · Low | |
| Gyorgy Bodrog New Bedford, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 11–11 | 292 | 26.5–26.5 | $50,124 | 2 · Low | |
| Alice Mary Graham-Brown Holyoke, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 23–23 | 443 | 19.3–19.3 | $69,541 | 0 · Low | |
| Howard Hernandez Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 21–21 | 397 | 18.9–18.9 | $68,177 | 0 · Low | |
| Piyush Johari Holyoke, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 23–38 | 352 | 9.3–15.3 | $57,406 | 0 · Low | |
| Ernesto Zilberberg North Andover, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 13–26 | 331 | 12.7–25.5 | $53,495 | 0 · Low | |
| Yousef Abou-Allaban Walpole, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90867, 90868 | 12–23 | 299 | 13.0–24.9 | $52,808 | 0 · Low | |
| David Morin Worcester, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 15–15 | 290 | 19.3–19.3 | $50,341 | 0 · Low | |
| Mark Eldaief Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 18–18 | 223 | 12.4–12.4 | $38,147 | 0 · Low | |
| Tracy Barbour Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 18–18 | 216 | 12.0–12.0 | $37,466 | 0 · Low | |
| Stephen Ikeda Plymouth, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 14–14 | 212 | 15.1–15.1 | $36,801 | 0 · Low | |
| Sahand Babapoorfarrokhran Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 18–18 | 120 | 6.7–6.7 | $20,831 | 0 · Low | |
| Ying Cao Belmont, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 31–31 | 109 | 3.5–3.5 | $19,024 | 0 · Low | |
| Roger Pottanat Weymouth, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 22–22 | 90 | 4.1–4.1 | $15,597 | 0 · Low | |
| Alice Uflacker Belmont, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 13–13 | 68 | 5.2–5.2 | $11,804 | 0 · Low | |
| Michael Kritzer-Cheren Boston, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 16–16 | 58 | 3.6–3.6 | $10,068 | 0 · Low | |
| Jennifer Gatchel Belmont, MA · Psychiatry Checking official directory… | 90868 | 19–19 | 33 | 1.7–1.7 | $5,728 | 0 · Low |
Massachusetts TMS billing indicator map
Ranked providers at CMS practice-city centroids, not street addresses. Providers sharing a city are spread apart.
Indicators: Same-code/setting peer outlier; 50%+ rise in upper-bound services/patient (denominator may change); Saved OIG LEIE NPI match. These are statistical prompts to look closer, not findings of fraud.
Ronald Winfield · 1679554927
North Chelmsford, MA · Psychiatry · $135,251
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 27 | 12–12 | 2.3–2.3 | $7,526 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 746 | 13–13 | 57.4–57.4 | $127,725 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 100 · High; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
90867 · Office · Services per patient above 99th percentile of peers: 2.25 vs peer median 1.05 · 185 peers (Psychiatry).
90868 · Office · Services per patient above 99th percentile of peers: 57.38 vs peer median 26.25 · 327 peers (Psychiatry).
Mahdi Razafsha · 1912293689
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $74,305
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 430 | 37–37 | 11.6–11.6 | $74,305 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 23 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
90868 · Facility · Patient count above 99th percentile of peers: 37.00 vs peer median 15.00 · 32 peers (Psychiatry).
Mathews Thomas · 1689790586
Brockton, MA · Psychiatry · $74,324
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 14 | 11–11 | 1.3–1.3 | $3,847 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 406 | 13–13 | 31.2–31.2 | $70,478 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 13 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Sabrina Dar · 1659866069
Waltham, MA · Psychiatry · $107,981
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 21 | 20–20 | 1.1–1.1 | $6,084 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 587 | 19–19 | 30.9–30.9 | $101,897 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 8 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Jonathan Schwartz · 1053393462
New Bedford, MA · Psychiatry · $401,396
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 69 | 65–65 | 1.1–1.1 | $20,514 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 2,181 | 77–77 | 28.3–28.3 | $376,139 |
| 90869 Motor-threshold re-determination + treatment | 19 | 19–19 | 1.0–1.0 | $4,742 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 5 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
John Zebrun · 1831170349
Northampton, MA · Psychiatry · $58,905
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 341 | 12–12 | 28.4–28.4 | $58,905 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 5 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Madhavi Kamireddi · 1255313466
Acton, MA · Psychiatry · $91,675
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 16 | 16–16 | 1.0–1.0 | $4,779 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 503 | 18–18 | 27.9–27.9 | $86,896 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 4 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
William Bache · 1619312774
Brockton, MA · Psychiatry · $50,500
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 292 | 11–11 | 26.5–26.5 | $50,500 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 2 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Gyorgy Bodrog · 1144425422
New Bedford, MA · Psychiatry · $50,124
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 292 | 11–11 | 26.5–26.5 | $50,124 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 2 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Alice Mary Graham-Brown · 1104887207
Holyoke, MA · Psychiatry · $69,541
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 443 | 23–23 | 19.3–19.3 | $69,541 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Howard Hernandez · 1508021213
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $68,177
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 397 | 21–21 | 18.9–18.9 | $68,177 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Piyush Johari · 1053379016
Holyoke, MA · Psychiatry · $57,406
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 15 | 15–15 | 1.0–1.0 | $3,814 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 337 | 23–23 | 14.7–14.7 | $53,592 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Ernesto Zilberberg · 1053346569
North Andover, MA · Psychiatry · $53,495
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 13 | 13–13 | 1.0–1.0 | $3,455 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 318 | 13–13 | 24.5–24.5 | $50,040 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Yousef Abou-Allaban · 1922040666
Walpole, MA · Psychiatry · $52,808
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90867 Initial treatment + motor-threshold determination | 11 | 11–11 | 1.0–1.0 | $3,285 |
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 288 | 12–12 | 24.0–24.0 | $49,523 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
David Morin · 1215910914
Worcester, MA · Psychiatry · $50,341
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 290 | 15–15 | 19.3–19.3 | $50,341 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Mark Eldaief · 1508971565
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $38,147
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 223 | 18–18 | 12.4–12.4 | $38,147 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Tracy Barbour · 1902190937
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $37,466
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 216 | 18–18 | 12.0–12.0 | $37,466 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Stephen Ikeda · 1619900198
Plymouth, MA · Psychiatry · $36,801
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 212 | 14–14 | 15.1–15.1 | $36,801 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Sahand Babapoorfarrokhran · 1326702168
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $20,831
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 120 | 18–18 | 6.7–6.7 | $20,831 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Ying Cao · 1538327523
Belmont, MA · Psychiatry · $19,024
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 109 | 31–31 | 3.5–3.5 | $19,024 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Roger Pottanat · 1396066874
Weymouth, MA · Psychiatry · $15,597
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 90 | 22–22 | 4.1–4.1 | $15,597 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Alice Uflacker · 1770861981
Belmont, MA · Psychiatry · $11,804
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 68 | 13–13 | 5.2–5.2 | $11,804 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Michael Kritzer-Cheren · 1578950549
Boston, MA · Psychiatry · $10,068
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 58 | 16–16 | 3.6–3.6 | $10,068 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Jennifer Gatchel · 1053632398
Belmont, MA · Psychiatry · $5,728
| Code / treatment | Services | Patient bounds | Services / patient | Medicare paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90868 Subsequent treatment | 33 | 19–19 | 1.7–1.7 | $5,728 |
Peer evidence
Screening score 0 · Low; highest same-code/setting shared peer score, not a probability of fraud.
No threshold flags in the available same-code/setting comparisons. This is not a clearance.
Sources and limitations
Medicare Part B fee-for-service only; Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and commercial claims are excluded. CMS suppresses provider-code rows with fewer than 11 beneficiaries. Patient counts overlap across codes and settings; bounds are not unique national patients. Annual aggregates cannot establish treatment courses, failure, medical necessity, duplicate visits or fraud. Coverage varies by Medicare contractor; no Spravato dosing thresholds are applied.
Peer groups use the same code and office/facility setting nationally, and the same CMS specialty with at least 20 providers; smaller specialties fall back to all providers in that code/setting. Score = positive ratio z-score × 12 + 18 per flag, capped at 100; a provider’s highest eligible code/setting score is shown. Year-to-year scores can move as peers change.
